The Jays return home after visiting the presumed AL Central champs, Detroit, and the less-credibly-presumed-to-be improved Royals with a 3-3 record. Not awful, considering how this road trip started.
Kansas City got their first taste of
Rah Dickey in 2013, and didn't like it much, scoring just 1 run over 6.1 innings. Contrast that with Dickey's last start against Boston - the Red Sux feasted on
Rah Dickey in Toronto, scoring 8 times (the Sux would presumably be very happy with a steady diet of
Rah Dickey, based on last week's results).
No,
you're a juvenile sense of humour.
Anyway, the bad news, you already know. Jose Reyes is gone for 3 months, give or take. That's disappointing, on several levels - Reyes is fun to watch, produces a lot of value at a premium position, and the Jays don't have any really good options for the leadoff spot, in his absence. However, two things can be taken away from the Reyes injury, not "silver linings"
per se, but perhaps bronze or electrum linings:
Despite what Buck and Pat were saying on yesterday's broadcast, Reyes is not the Jays' best defender at shortstop. I've
been over this already; Reyes is a great hitter, but not as good defensively as Yunel Escobar. It's arguable (see Fangraphs, for example) that Maicer Izturis is as good as Reyes in the field, and the shortstop
de jour, Munenori Kawasaki, is a 2-time Gold Glove winner in Japan and looked pretty solid in the field this weekend. Sure, small sample size, but Reyes's injury is a disaster only in the sense that he can't be replaced offensively in general, and in the leadoff spot in particular. The defense at shortstop will be fine.
Secondly... (I know, this is the sort of intangible-based argument that I normally sneer at) Reyes's injury may force other players to step up their game, and make the team better overall. Remember, last year's Blue Jay team was at or near the top of the AL in runs scored, before the injuries hit. That team had Yunel Escobar and Kelly Johnson, and they've been supplanted by Reyes, Cabrera, and Izturis/Bonifacio in 2013. So, realistically, it's not as if this year's team is hurting for offensive potential, in Reyes's absence. And if the Jays can hang in the playoff race (and I believe they will), they'll get a huge boost when Reyes comes back in July.
(Assuming he has no setbacks and returns as scheduled in July... but I don't want to think about the alternative.)
So moving on to the good news: Dickey played well, Morrow played well, and Happ, while not as sharp as he was against Boston, was good enough to keep the Jays in Friday's game (that they eventually won). Now if Buehrle and Johnson can right themselves, we'll be in business, even if Rajai Davis is the new leadoff hitter.
Jose Bautista has been receiving plaudits for his heroically volunteering to play 3B following the Reyes injury. Huh, what?? I mean, good for him for putting his hand up, I guess, but that was really the only move the Jays could have made on Friday. With Izturis and Reyes hurt, what was Jose going to say, "No, I won't play 3B. Let Bonifacio play 3B and see if we can make a trade with the Pirates and fly Russell Martin in to play shortstop, during the injury delay"? I would hope that a professional baseball player who has THREE THOUSAND innings of experience at a defensive position would be willing to play that position in an emergency. Anyway... my thinking was that Jose would be at 3B until Brett Lawrie came off the DL. That would be fine, considering Lawrie is expected back within days... but now, there's word that Lawrie played second base today in Dunedin...
...No, no, no. Do we have to go over this again? Brett Lawrie is a very good third baseman. He hasn't played second base in over 2 years. Putting Lawrie at 2B and Bautista at 3B does... what, exactly? Free up Bonifacio for shortstop - no, Bonifacio isn't a good shortstop. Keep both Lawrie and J-Bau in the lineup? No, they would be in the lineup anyway. The only thing an infield that includes both Lawrie and Bautista does is ensure that the Jays don't have to expose an outfielder (Casper Wells?) to waivers. Well, that, and making the infield defense worse, of course. When Lawrie comes back, he should be at 3B, Bautista in RF, Izturis (or Kawasaki or someone else) at short, and Bonifacio (or Izturis) at second. Neither of the Jays' backup outfielders (Rajai Davis, Casper Wells) merits being played every day at the expense of the infield defense. OK? Thanks.
Finally, from the
DJF comments section, one for the "I wish I had said that" archives:
Better to have Lo Viste’d and lost than to have never Lo Viste’d at all.
Get well soon, Jose.